fv_poster | Gift for Isis by valoise (The Grapes of Wrath)

Skip to Main Content

Crossposts: http://fv-poster.livejournal.com/132901.html

Entry tags:

Gift for Isis by valoise (The Grapes of Wrath)

Title of vid: Who Will Comfort Me
Recipient: Isis
Vidder: valoise
Fandom: The Grapes of Wrath (1940)
Music: Who Will Comfort Me by Melody Gardot
Summary: With a family torn by poverty and turmoil and heartache, Ma Joad's strength holds them together.
Content notes: No standardized notes apply
Signed length: 03:09

Flat | Top-Level Comments Only

What a fabulous and heart-tugging character study. You do a great job of showing how Ma Joad is the family's center. It's a strong and sad movie, and the clips you've chosen underline both the strength and the sadness.

The song is lovely, a perfect fit, both in the lyrics and in the mood it sets.

Thank you!

I'm so glad you liked it. That means a lot.

Amazingly poignant. Wow.

Thanks.

wonderful song choice, beautifully made. And so sad.

Glad you liked it!

Really lovely and so well put together, great song choice!

Thanks so much.

Oh, this is wonderful.

Thank you!

Damn, I have tears in my eyes. Lovely and painful.

Happy to have made you sad! Seriously, it's such a complement to have moved people with the vid.

Love the song choice and the way the vid moves & feels with the music.

Thanks so much, I really appreciate it.

This was wonderful. I liked best the section before the two minute mark, the journeying, but all of it was really well done.

Thanks!

Oh my goodness. What a wonderful Ma Joad character study, really well done. Painful and strong and beautiful.

Glad you liked it. Jane Darwell so deserved the Oscar she got for that roll, her strength was so fantastic to vid.

Very powerful.

Thank you.

Holy crap, this was gutting. In a good way, but still gutting!

Glad you found it so moving.

Flat | Top-Level Comments Only